It’s a baby. It’s a breast. Enough already.
April 23, 2007 by Barbara Behrmann | one question or comment
I’ve written about this before (see the links below), but new confrontations sadly keep the issue from becoming passe. The latest incident happened at none other than the otherwise wonderful Ronald McDonald House (RMH). Usually a haven housing families whose children are receiving medical treatment for cancer and other serious illnesses, the Ronald McDonald House in Houston damaged its reputation by asking Jessica Swimeley to stop nursing one of her 17 month-old twins in a communal dining area after another father complained. Jessica’s room, three floors up, was the only acceptable place to nurse and if she didn’t comply, she could be kicked out. The reason? “Sensitivity” to the house’s “multicultural residents.”
The irony is stunning. Jessica, 27, was nursing her son who was recovering from surgery to remove a brain tumor. What does breast milk do? It boosts the immune system and may even kill cancer cells! Equally important, as Jessica explained, nursing is the only thing that makes her son feel better. Instead of being admonished, Jessica should have been applauded for meeting her child’s physical and emotional needs.
After Jessica’s internet savvy sister took the issue public and after a meeting between RMH administrators, La Leche League, and Jessica and her family, RMH agreed that Jessica could stay as long as she nursed discreetly and “announced her intention to nurse” giving anyone who would be offended the chance to leave. But any future complaints and she could be kicked out.
Apart from my inability to see how one can “discreetly” announce one’s intention to nurse (wouldn’t it be more discreet to simply go about it quietly?), the bottom line is that RMH has thus far missed a fabulous opportunity to revisit its guidelines, educate its staff throughout the whole organization, and make it clear, in writing, that nursing mothers and babies are welcome and supported. And they failed to see that their treatment of Jessica is blatantly against Texas state law. As of 1995, Chapter 165 of the Texas Health and Safety Code, reads as follows: “A mother is entitled to breast-feed her baby in any location in which the mother is authorized to be.” Not any bedroom in which a mother is authorized to be, but any location, period.
It may be too much to ask each and every individual for understanding and approval of women’s rights, but isn’t it time for organizations and institutions that serve the public to recognize them? And to make sure their policies and programs are breastfeeding-friendly? Why wait to take action defensively? Why not do it proactively?
As far as Jessica and the Ronald McDonald House, please consider writing to Naomi Scott, Executive Director of Houston’s Ronald McDonald House, to insist that RMH create explicitly breastfeeding-friendly policies and educate its employees on the issue. Copies of your letter should be sent to Susie Richard, Director of Operations and Arlene Whatley, Hollcombe House Director of Operations. You can also telephone the organization’s headquarters at 630-623-7048 to express your concerns.
For future updates visit The Reluctant Lactivist and for more information read the following links that can be found at The Breastfeeding Cafe.
Beyond the Nursery: Nursing with Confidence
Summertime and the Living is …Not so Easy!
Stop Harassing Nursing Mothers










It’s amazing how readily society seems to accept that breasts are fine for the pleasure of men, but our children who need them for nutrition and comfort are sadly looked upon as undeserving.